| 1964 | e Camus John CSB 98, USAS 15 | - OH Heather Buck's Roan USAM 352 |
| 1965 | e Oak Hills Killeaney John USAS 61 | - Oak Hills Katie USAM 570 |
| 1966 | e Killeaney's Blazing Greyhound USAS 182 | - Oak Hills Triumph USAM 578 |
| 1968 | e Camus John's Gladiator USAS 237 | - Oak Hills Triumphant USAM 712 |
| 1969 | e Camus John's Gladiator USAS 237 | - Oak Hills Jameson USAS 276 |
| 1970 | e Camus John's Gladiator USAS 237 | - Oak Hills Brandy Bay G 281 |
| 1971 | e Oak Hills Trocardi USAS 273 | - Oak Hills Sweet Briar USAM 881 |
| 1972 | e Camus John's Gladiator USAS 237 | - Oak Hill's Eric G 262 |
| 1973 | e Camus John's Gladiator USAS 237 | - Oak Hills Sweet Ashley USAM 1172 |